Hexabromocyclododecane in herring gull eggs: Declining concentrations since the beginning of the 2000s

In eggs of herring gulls from the North Sea and the Baltic Sea only alpha-HBCD was detected in all samples whereas the concentrations of the two other diastereomers beta and gamma of technical HBCD were near or below the limit of quantification. At all three sampling sites HBCD levels were highest in 2000 and declined significantly thereafter.

Hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) is a brominated flame retardant. Technical HBCD is a mixture of different diastereomers, each of which consists of a pair of enantiomers ((-)/(+)). The major component is gamma-HBCD which makes up for 75-89%, followed by beta-HBCD (10-13%) and alpha-HBCD (1-12%). HBCD is mainly used in polystyrene foams used for thermal insulation of buildings but it is also present in, e.g., housings of computers and TVs and back-coatings of textiles used in upholstery. HBCD is very effective and small amounts are sufficient to obtain the desired level of protection. Nevertheless, traces of HBCD are found in all environmental compartments today.

In the environment HBCD is persistent. It accumulates strongly in organisms and in the food web and is highly toxic to aquatic organisms. Because of these PBT-properties (Persistent, Bioaccumulative, Toxic) HBCD is classified as SVHC (substance of very high concern) under the REACh-Regulation. Furthermore, its inclusion in Annex 1 of the Stockholm Convention is discussed.

However, since no adequate alternatives exist, the use of HBCD is currently not restricted despite its unfavourable properties. In recent years, the manufacturers and processors of HBCD have initiated several programmes to reduce and control HBCD emissions (e.g., VECAP - Voluntary Emissions Control Action Programme and SECURE - Self Enforced Control of Use to Reduce Emissions).

Map of the sampling sites Trischen, Mellum, Heuwiese
Fig. 1: Map of the sampling sites Trischen, Mellum, Heuwiese Zoom in

To obtain an impression of the HBCD contamination of biota in German coastal waters, a retrospective monitoring was performed using herring gull egg pools from three sites at the North Sea and the Baltic Sea.

 

 

 

Results

Total HBCD concentrations (sum of all diastereomers) in herring gull eggs from the North Sea sampling sites Trischen and Mellum ranged between 13.8 and 74.8 ng/g lipid weight (lw) and 4.17-107 ng/g lw, respectively. In eggs from the Baltic Sea island Heuwiese total HBCD varied between 25.1-98.7 ng/g lw.

Of the three main diastereomers in technical HBCD only alpha-HBCD was detected in all egg samples whereas levels of beta- and gamma-HBCD were mostly below the LOQ. Levels of (-)-alpha-HBCD were slightly higher than those of (+)-alpha-HBCD in all samples.

Time trends were similar at all three sampling sites with peak concentrations around 2000 and declines thereafter.

During the monitoring period from 1988 to 2008, herring gull eggs from the North Sea island Trischen had mean (-)-alpha-HBCD levels of 7.7-41.1 ng/g lw and mean (+)-alpha-HBCD levels of 5.9-31.2 ng/g lw. After 2000, contamination decreased significantly to levels below the initial values.

Slightly higher HBCD contents were detected in gull eggs from the North Sea island Mellum, i.e. 2.1-66 ng/g lw (-)-alpha-HBCD and 1.7-40.8 ng/g lw (+)-alpha-HCBD. Again, concentrations peaked around 2000 and decreased afterwards. However, the decrease was somehow delayed and it was not before 2008 that 50% of the peak concentrations were reached.

At the Baltic Sea island Heuwiese monitoring started only in 1998. Mean HBCD levels in herring gull eggs ranged between 13.3-52.0 ng/g lw for (-)-alpha-HBCD and 11.6-44.7 ng/g lw for (+)-alpha-HBCD. A significant decline was observed after 2002 and levels were well below the initial values in 2008.

alpha-HBCD concentrations in herring gull eggs from the North Sea islands Mellum and Trischen and the Baltic Sea island Heuwiese
Fig. 2: alpha-HBCD concentrations in herring gull eggs from the North Sea islands Mellum and Trischen and the Baltic Sea island Heuwiese Zoom in

 

Significance of the findings

Even though gamma-HBCD is the major diastereomer in technical HBCD, the alpha-diastereomer dominates in herring gull eggs. These findings are in accordance with earlier studies. Three possible reasons are discussed in this context: (1) a better bioavailability of alpha-HBCD because of its higher water solubility, (2) a biotransformation of gamma- and beta-HBCD to alpha-HBCD, and (3) a rapid metabolisation of gamma- and beta-HBCD resulting in a dominance of the more stable alpha-diastereomer.

The observed decline in HBCD contamination of herring gull eggs at all three sampling sites suggests that the measures taken to reduce emissions have been effective and/or that HBCD consumption has decreased in recent years.

Recommended profiles

Specimen

Herring gull Inshore, the herring gull mainly feeds from the sea: upon fish, mussels, and crabs.

Analytes

Hexabromocyclododecane Brominated flame retardant in polystyrene foams and other plastics

Sampling area

Heuwiese Bird protection island in the northern part of the Kubitzer Bodden.
Trischen Bird island in the Schleswig-Holstein Wadden Sea.
Mellum Bird island in the Lower Saxon Wadden Sea

Extended information

Literature